In this blog, EDN Editorial Director Maury Wright focuses on digital consumer-electronics gadgets and the converged networks that feed them with video, audio, and data. [Editor's note: As of Feb. 2008, this blog is no longer active and is presented here for archival purposes.]
Advertisement
Profile
RSS Feed
-
Add this blog to your RSS newsreader!
Recent Posts
- OLED Sony TV shines at CES from afar
- Blu-ray might have won, but is there a prize?
- Analyst broadband projections still miss the point
- Broadband reach is still the issue despite congestion projections
- Wireless USB exec questions press reviews based on actual specs
- So Cal fires trump technology: catastrophe pales in Katrina comparison
- Could females close the presumed engineer shortage in the US?
- Municipal Wi-Fi press exceeds deployment
- Complete survey, win iPod Touch
- Halo 3 doubtful as a console success predictor
Recent Comments
- LaptopAces on UWB Forum moves toward coexistence, while WiMedia may get Bluetooth name
- Fierce on UWB Forum moves toward coexistence, while WiMedia may get Bluetooth name
- Steave on Complete survey, win iPod Touch
- Polprav on Maney right on with convenience and fidelity stand
- baibreenliste on UWB Forum moves toward coexistence, while WiMedia may get Bluetooth name
Most Commented On
- UWB Forum moves toward coexistence, while WiMedia may get Bluetooth name (83)
- Super camera handles video, still images, and MP3 playback (47)
- Free WiMAX download from In-Stat (23)
- Merger Mania: Cingular and AT&T get worse (23)
- Super camera web site deceives with posted review (21)
Archives
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- February 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
- October 2005
- September 2005
- August 2005
- July 2005
- June 2005
- May 2005
- April 2005
- March 2005
- February 2005
- January 2005
- December 2004
- November 2004
By Category
- 3G (2)
- ADSL/DSL (1)
- Analog (2)
- Audio (7)
- Auto (1)
- Broadband (8)
- Broadband (53)
- Business and Marketing (24)
- Business News (1)
- Capital Equipment (1)
- Carriers & Services (1)
- Cellular Phones (1)
- Communication functions (49)
- Communications & Networking (4)
- Communications Engineering (1)
- Components, Hardware, Interconnect (1)
- Computer Technology & Internet (2)
- Computers (1)
- Computers, boards, buses (19)
- Connected Home (10)
- Consumer Products (5)
- Convergence (127)
- Data Storage (2)
- Digital ICs (41)
- Digital TV (1)
- DSP (2)
- DVD (1)
- Electronics Careers & Training (2)
- Electronics Engineering Education (2)
- Electronics Engineering Salaries (1)
- Embedded Processors (1)
- Embedded Systems (11)
- Fiber-optic (1)
- Fibre Optics (1)
- Global (4)
- Government/Legal (3)
- HDTV (1)
- Home Entertainment (3)
- Home Network (1)
- Home Networking (1)
- Imaging (1)
- Industrial-Embedded Computing (1)
- Infrastructure (3)
- LAN (1)
- Libraries & Algorithms (1)
- Licensing & Technology Agreements (1)
- Memory components (1)
- Mobile (6)
- Multimedia (68)
- Music/Audio (7)
- Packaging (1)
- People (1)
- Peripherals (14)
- Personal Communications (1)
- Power Sources/Controllers (1)
- Processors & Tools (17)
- Semiconductors (8)
- Society & Culture (1)
- Software (8)
- Software Engineering (1)
- Standards (29)
- Standards (2)
- Standards (1)
- Storage devices (2)
- Storage Devices (1)
- System Engineering (1)
- Telecommunications (1)
- Test and Measurement (1)
- TV (1)
- UWB (1)
- Video (1)
- Video (2)
- Video/DTV (10)
- Voice (2)
- Wired (1)
- Wired Networks (2)
- Wireless (61)
- Wireless Networks (3)
Communications/Network Design Articles
- 3.3V mixer downconverts RF with good linearity
- Device enables remote computer control and management
- Keep your hands off my Internet content
- 10GBase-T: Is it really coming this time?
- Cyborg crickets could create cooperative community networks
- More...
Blog
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Municipal Wi-Fi press exceeds deployment
Sep 27 2007 6:37AM | Permalink |Comments (1) |
I just wrote a municipal Wi-Fi column for the next print issue of EDN about issues with planned deployments. A number of experts are suddenly questioning the validity of the concept, although most question the technical difficulties and cost. I think the real issue is that there is no one to pay for the service. I went looking for some more input on the topic and here are a bunch of quick links that you might find interesting.
Here’s a breakdown of how municipal Wi-Fi works from the How Stuff Works web site.
Here’s a blog devoted to public broadband.
Here’s a story on municipal Wi-Fi success stories in small communities.
Here’s another bleak outlook story from The Economist.
Here’s an index to a large set of articles on eWeek.
I suppose the one final thought that I have centers again on the value proposition. How did a company like Earthlink believe that financially strapped large cities were going to fund these massive deployments? Here’s a link to the recent Earthlink restructuring announcement. The announcement didn’t call out municipal Wi-Fi as the culprit but read where the staff reductions are concentrated and the message is clear. And despite all of the bad news, I’d suspect some small tows and cities to still do quite well with municipal Wi-Fi.
Related entries in: Communications & Networking | Infrastructure | Wireless Networks |
Reader Comments
at 11/15/2007 5:36:06 PM, GerwingR said:
Well stated Maury Wright:
"Not at this time, until the fee for service is worked out." rtg.
Post a comment
About Us | Contact Us | Free Email Newsletters | Free Magazine Subscription | Advertising | 
RSS
©1997-2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy