Zibb

Paul RakoTechnical Editor Paul Rako looks at analog technology in power supplies, interface, the signal path, and life in general.



   Advertisement

Profile

RSS Feed

  • Add this blog to your RSS newsreader!

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Most Commented On

Archives

By Category

Analog Design Articles

Blog

Wednesday, April 4, 2007

PCB road-kill

Apr 4 2007 8:43AM | Permalink |Comments (18) |


So I went to drop off some letters around the corner and as I walked around the block I came upon these three circuit boards in the gutter of the road. Only in Silicon Valley do you find road-kill like this. The boards are all scuffed up but that is no reason not to learn from them. You can click on the images for a bigger view.

Circuit boardsThe road-kill I found in the gutter. The middle one is a JDS Uniphase board. Neat routing and very sophisticated. The top and bottom boards are nice WinSystems single board computers. The boards are covered with scuff marks from tire tracks, just ignore that damage.

JDS_Uniphase_PCBHere is a close-up of the JDS Uniphase board. Note how it is routed out with breakaway tabs. This allows a nice rectangular board for the board house to send through the solder machine and maybe even into a test fixture. Once everything is inspected and OK they can break the board out of the outside. Notice the “thieving” the squares of copper on the outside areas. On inner layers it allows the laminate glue to flow and balance, on the outside layers it evens the acid etch and reduces warping. The local fab house, Proto Express has started to add this thieving to blank areas on their no-touch boards. Problem is us analog guys often really want no copper under some low-capacitance nodes. Proto Express told me to send a note with the board to not add thieving or it will be added automatically. Also note the tool-holes in the corner of the board. These tool holes hold the many layers in alignment while the layers are being laminated together. And there is a target —the little solder dot that is just diagonally inside the tool-hole. Note there is a target on the rounded corner of the routed out layer too. This is for lining up laminate layers and for registration of the pick-and-place machine that puts the parts down on the board in assembly.

PCB Trace damageHere is why the WinSytems board was in the gutter— this tag was still on it. It failed optical inspection. A darn good board house or assembly house did this inspection. Why assemble a marginal board with valuable components? Trash the board and save the risk folks.

PCB netlist errorAnother shot of the JDS Uniphase board. The yellow sticker might mean it failed electrical test. I don’t see anything visually wrong with this net, but it may be open or shorted inside the board.

BGA fanout 1What a nice fan out.

BGA fanout 2Another fan-out.

Odd PCB footprintHere is the interesting footprint on the back of the JDS Uniphase board. Anybody know what this does?


Related entries in: Analog | Computers, boards, buses | 


Reader Comments



at 4/4/2007 9:12:21 AM, RobertD said:
Well, I would think that when viewed from above, it probably indicates the optimium landing zone for alien spacecraft. Otherwise, it is a very interesting footprint.



at 4/5/2007 1:26:38 PM, trr said:
you got everything right except one thing - the tooling holes in the corners are not used for aligning the layers during lamination - they were likely drilled during the routing step when the board was routed out of its panel.

The lamination tooling holes are in an area of solid copper at the midpoint of each panel edge, with one hole offset slightly to prevent laying up the innerlayers in the wrong orientation (the so-called Multiline tooling system). Those holes are punched, not drilled, into the layers individually by a machine that aligns the holes based on the copper patterns after etching and is therefore called a post-etch punch. They are often a circle with flats on both sides.

After lamination, if some epoxy (or polyimide, etc. depending on the type of prepreg used) flows out around the holes they might have to be spotfaced or drilled. This would be a big problem if the layers didn''t have solid copper around these holes, causing a high pressure area to drive the epoxy away from them. From all this discussion, it may sound like I was a PCB lamination engineer or something. OK, I admit it.



at 4/5/2007 2:29:39 PM, Bill S said:
The cool looking footprints appear to be for two "Arrayed-Wavelength Grating"s. These can combine or split light - thus the MUX & DEMUX in the silkscreen.



at 4/6/2007 8:21:41 AM, DDW said:
I would want to know which manufacturer’s logo is on the board. Is this not considered hazardous waste?



at 4/6/2007 10:17:08 AM, pjr said:
I qwould want to know the manufacturer as well. I would be a little upset if my board waspickedup in the street by a competitor. Can determine all kinds of things from the board.



at 4/6/2007 12:09:36 PM, trr said:
DDW asked if it was haz waste. I'd say definitely no if it were lead-free solder on the pads and "probably not" if it were tin-lead solder, nevertheless it is something that should be recycled.
I did notice one other error in your write-up (I previously said only one): etching outerlayers (and usually innerlayers as well is done by an alkaline ammonia solution, not by acid.
I can see a date code of 4306 (43rd week of 2006) on the middle board in the top picture but any fab identifier is too blurry to make out.



at 4/17/2007 2:14:12 PM, KE5FX said:
On the arrayed-pad question, it could be worth asking Bunnie Huang, who runs the "Name That Ware" contest from his blog at www.bunniestudios.com/blog/ . Besides being a true hardware-hacker's hacker, he has a cadre of loyal readers who have proven _very_ hard to stump.



at 4/17/2007 2:29:28 PM, Hal said:
I would guess that these boards fell off the back of a recycling truck, especially since they are from two very different companies.



at 4/17/2007 3:03:53 PM, MPS-AZ said:
As an escapee from Silicon Valley and now in the Phoenix area, I find hi-tech refuse, a la "road kill" often. The majority of victims are cell phones and hend-held gaming devices. Some of these are great sources for components suitable for various projects from breadboards to Ham Radio prototypes. With so much usability in their after-life, renaming "road kill" to "roadise surplus" might be apropos. 73-M



at 4/17/2007 3:38:49 PM, Photos said:
If you turn off the flash and use a tripod, the pictures would be much better. It's difficult to see any of the small features, and the areas the flash over-exposed are obscured. Otherwise, it's interesting to see how other people design boards. Thanks for sharing.



at 4/17/2007 4:30:10 PM, djam said:

The best pictures of boards with or with components can be done with a flat bed scanner. Give it a try you might be surprised as I was when I was told how well it worked.



at 4/17/2007 10:32:21 PM, minchio said:
it''''s quite simple! the arrayed pad is used to position a new technology of space save integrated circuits with that pin disposition



at 4/19/2007 3:31:39 PM, foxtail said:
The pink pad finish on the last picture is a Flux finish. It is an alternative to lead free solder hot air leveling (LFHASL or LFHAL). Flux finish has a short shelf life (around 3 months max), but attaches well to leaded and lead free solders. It also has the advantage of being very flat, where HASL finishes are often quite uneven and lumpy. People are moving away from Gold finishes and Milspec wont allow gold, as it can react and leach with solder. I found that Gold finishes require more heat and dont spread as well (wetting). Flux finish has great spread and lower temperature attachment then solder finishes.



at 4/19/2007 3:54:25 PM, M Chibnik said:
The mystery solder pattern seems to me to be for the attacment of a arrayed waveguide grating(AWG) which was probably set up for a wavelength division multiplexer for an optical network. Electrical contacts could have been for temperature stabilaztion or for optical channel level monitoring or even for MEMs optical switches.

If I were one of these companies I'd be worrying about how my vendors handle all materials concering my product line.



at 4/23/2007 11:43:18 PM, Paul Rako said:
foxtail, thanks for the tip about the Flux Finish, my buddy John just asked about getting products into Europe and I told him some people favor gold immersion since it cannot be mistaken for Sn/Pb solder. This looks like another way to have that different look but I am sure it must cost less.

And Mr Chibnik, thanks for a really perceptive comment. In addition your comments on companies vendors is good too. In my experience any competitor has bought the entire system and stole the source code so some analog guy like me posting the PCB should be more valued for marketing than feared for IP protection. If they gripe I will certainly take down the pictures since I am a nice guy, even though the post is a clear case of fair use.



at 4/24/2007 2:32:57 PM, trr said:
I haven't heard the term Flux Finish before. OSP (organic solderability preservative) is the term I've heard.

Macdermid, Enthone and other vendors make OSP chemistries. None of them call their product flux though. They are benzimidiazole or benzotriazole based and form a corrosion resistant layer on the copper. There is a shelf life concern but I think you can reasonably expect more than three months.



at 6/13/2007 7:21:27 PM, WENZHOU ZHICHENG ELECTRONICS CO.,LTD said:
I feel rather confused by your complicated technical discussions. Of course not to offense but it is much more convenient for the majority to buy from manufacturers. And,company specializes in design of high qualities PCB, made, sale and service.The year production of single layer and two layers PCB is up to 130,000 square meters. with the principle of excellent production and speedy delivery, we also keep pace of the new technology, warmly hope establish business relationship with you to get nmutual benefit!welcome to our website:www.pcbmanufacturer.cn or send E-mail:trade@pcbmanufacturer.cn




at 4/7/2008 10:07:17 PM, polyimide said:
Have you read about the polyimide? Here's the link for the article
profma.com

Post a comment



Display Name

Change Image
Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above.
Note the letters are NOT case sensitive.


ADVERTISEMENT

©1997-2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other Reed Business sites