For this supply chain blog, Electronic News has recruited some of the supply chain’s most influential executives who are truly linked into the market to contribute their views of the industry and its most critical topics -- RoHS, distribution, WEEE, parts databases, inventory levels, pricing, China RoHS or whatever else comes up in this ever evolving business channel. Come back to Critical Links often to see what these executives have to say about the supply chain and join the conversation by blogging back with your comments.


Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Buying gray could cost you a lot of green

Apr 10 2007 6:25AM | Permalink | Email this | Comments (9) |
Blog This! using:  Blogger.com | LiveJournal |
Digg This | Slashdot This | add to Del.icio.us


While counterfeit parts are not a new problem for the industry, it is a persistent one, and in light of the newest RoHS law in China, it’s more important than ever to know that the parts you spec are the parts you get. Later this year, China RoHS will require that vendor compliance is confirmed through a Chinese test house. That’s not when you want to find out that you have purchased bogus parts.

The irony? A large number of counterfeit parts sold in this country originate in China. China’s loose enforcement of intellectual property laws and convoluted electronics supply chains are well documented.

Not trading in China or not concerned about compliant parts? Counterfeit parts come in a lot of varieties, and one counterfeit component that’s not performing to your specifications can take down your whole line.

And if that component finds its way onto the market and out to customers, it’s likely to cause even costlier problems with service calls, warranty issues—maybe even leading to a recall. No restitution can be expected from the purported vendor as it is not their product.

There is, of course, a greater temptation to source from the gray market when the parts you need are in short supply or you were quoted a fantastic price. Since some buyers gets paid on PPV (purchase price variance) and the company can take advantage of the super price, why not make the deal? DON’T DO IT! It’s not that brokers are necessarily dishonest, it’s the fact that they typically can’t provide real traceability (such as a certificate of compliance or date/lot code), as they usually don’t know the original source of the parts.

eBay and other Internet sites should also be avoided as sources for components. Passive components (especially surface mount product) are easy marks for counterfeiters. Once they come off a reel, there’s no marking on the individual part.

It may sound self-serving, but buying components from a franchised distributor or directly from a manufacturer, are the only two ways you can have real confidence that you’re getting what you ordered. It’s not worth risking long-term financial exposure to you and your company for short-term savings.

NEDA (National Electronic Distributions Association) has taken a strong position on this matter. They have provided a simple letter to be used by distributors to communicate the confidence the customer should have buying from an authorized, franchised distributor. Make sure you’re making the purchasing decisions today that are right for your business tomorrow.

This blog post was contributed by Jeff Shafer, senior VP of product at Newark. At Newark, Jeff leads product management, product data, pricing and customer segment strategy, and was instrumental in developing and implementing RoHS compliance initiatives for the company, customers and suppliers.


Related entries in: Environmental Compliance | 


Reader Comments


at 4/10/2007 1:05:44 PM, Bogus parts said:
Bogus parts burn source manufacturers too. We have had customers return "defective" parts that they insisted they had purchased from our distributor only to find the parts had our markings on the top of the package but a mold mark symbol of another company molded into the bottom of the package.

at 4/10/2007 1:18:32 PM, Schuyler Glidden said:
This article is quite right in the view that not buying from franchise can be dangerous to your line. You should only buy from known, well established 10+ years companies that have a strong financial backing. Also make sure that your Grey market supplier carries "errors and omissions" insurance. It is expensive and will protect your company. These policies are quite expensive and seperate the suppliers quite nicely into the ''''haves and have nots". If your broker does not have full liability insurance on the parts he sells - do not place the order. Like any supplier do the research, talk to others, and get references that are current. The days of buying from some guy out of the back of his garage on his cell phone are long gone.

at 4/10/2007 1:53:08 PM, ww said:
interesting point

at 4/10/2007 5:05:21 PM, two cents worth.... said:
It is easier said than done. For a small company like us, we often have no choice but to buy from the Gray market. The original part manufacturers' capacity are often fully booked by the big MNCs weeks or months in advance. Small players like us will have to wait for the distributor to accummulate the orders before placing the order with the manufacturer. And in this industry, lead time is the key.

at 4/10/2007 5:29:13 PM, Richard A. Bean said:
While bogus parts present a "financial loss" variable in the immediate and future equation, there is another factor that was not mentioned. What of the possibilites of real casualties either in property loss or loss of life in mission-critical systems. This opens up an entire new can of worms does it not?

at 4/10/2007 6:48:40 PM, DGM said:
Wow, that is amazing. Is Newark really that scared about competition from the Gray Market that it now has to publicly bash us? What he fails to mention is that Newark Sales Reps and most other Franchises have the green light to broker parts.

at 4/11/2007 4:50:29 PM, MAM said:
DGM, The article doesn't protect Newark MS. The article informs purchasing folks of dangers in taking risk through purchasing from lower tier suppliers. It gives a recommendation for protecting your company profitability, and customer trust. Buyer beware...

at 4/17/2007 1:28:56 PM, FraudFighter said:
Most buyers avoid the smaller brokers and stick to an AVL of the biggest brokers. the problem is that counterfeit is so good these days, the big brokers have no way of stopping these parts either. Insurance is great, but when you have a looming shortage, you can't be picky. The buyers at the catalog and franchised distributors will buy from brokers too, on occassion, and they will have no ability to screen bogus parts. Mr. Bean is right: who holds the liability for injuries when counterfeit hurts someone?

at 4/23/2007 10:23:09 PM, Dara Khan said:
As a former credit manager for an Electronics Commodity Broker it is key to keep your supplier and customer relationships transparent at all times. It is very easy for the salesman or buyer to get caught up in the sale or buy and forget about the protection of a business' number one asset, the cash. Often the buyer and salesperson are put in a position to make these determinations and this if far more dangerous as often they have their personal interests at heart and not the organizational goals first as they are commission driven. This is not their role but the credit departments role. It is more important now to have credit professionals who understand the ins and outs of the global environment. This is a dynamic arena. It often frustrated me to see companies fail to give the same type of scrutiny to a supplier''s credit, often there was no collaboration between the buyer and the credit professional determining the quality of the product or creditworthiness of a supplier from the purchasing standpoint. If you are scrutinizing your customer to get paid the same emphasis should be put on the supplier relationship. If you are working in a global environment it should not be your purchaser''s responsibility to find out if the supplier''s reputation is viable. In this saturated Chinese market a company simply cannot afford to leave the decision of managing cash or product solely with a buyer or salesrep. It is important to have a valuable credit department on hand. The credit department is the eyes and ears of the industry, they listen to every aspect whether or not it is pertinent to the eminent sale or buy, this is the very information which often holds more then the immediate sale. If you use your credit department wisely you will learn things which are easily missed, a lot of companies fail to see a sale is only completed when the last dollar is in the bank. Sales people and buyers are driven by commission, credit professionals are not and they are very conservative people who manage information and siphon it to the people who need it most, it gives causation to why it is even more important to listen to the recommendations and information coming from your credit professional. As a credit professional I would rather like to be proactive and have done the due diligence of knowing deeply the supplier and customer position within the industry prior to the sale so the reactive piece of insurance is just a cushion and not a lifesaver.

Post a comment


Display Name

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above:


ADVERTISEMENT

©1997-2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other Reed Business sites

ADVERTISEMENT
You will be redirected to your destination in few seconds.