Advertisement

Zibb

EDA GRAFFITI, WITH EDA VETERAN PAUL MCLELLAN, DIGS INTO THE WORLD OF DESIGN TO FIND OUT HOW WE GOT HERE, WHERE WE ARE GOING, AND WHY EDA IS DIFFERENT.



   Advertisement

Thursday, June 25, 2009

Guest blog: Soha Hassoun

Jun 25 2009 12:00AM | Permalink |Comments (4) |


DAC is coming up late July, as I’m sure you know. For the first time this year there is a real user track in which users, unmoderated by EDA marketing droids, can talk about their experiences. Soha Hassoun of Tufts University was the person who didn’t step three paces back fast enough and so found herself volunteered as Design Community chair. Of course, her first question to answer was: what is a design community chair? And the last question, what flavors of ice-cream do users prefer?

My design community: the users

It’s three and a half weeks before DAC—and we, the executive committee and organizer MP Associates—are in the final stages of preparing for the User Track at DAC.  It’s been a joy ride, with some ups and downs.

I was recruited about a year ago to be the Design Community Chair for DAC.  I said I would take the job only if I can re-define what that role means. Andrew Kahng, DAC’s chair, agreed and signed me up.  

The questions began: What is a design community? Does it even exist? And, in what forms? How far does it stretch? And, if these design communities already are associated with established conferences, why would they be interested in connecting with DAC? Can we characterize the profile of a typical “design community member”?

Well, after dwelling on these questions for a few days, looking at years’ worth of survey data from DAC, chatting with members of the DAC Executive Committee and many colleagues designing hardware and software, two ideas crystallized.  First, DAC in the past has had a hard time identifying with a “design community.”  Second, the common characteristic of members of this “design community” was that they “use EDA tools.”

Bingo!  That was it.  The “design community” label is potentially a mismatch: we were really talking about the “EDA Tool Users.” Relief.  At least now we decoded the word “Design” in “Design Community,” and we started talking about “User Community.”  

The quest shifted to find a way of connecting a large community, scattered geographically and topically, yet focused on EDA tool use.  What would bring members of this EDA User Community to DAC?  Certainly not to shop for tools.   The user community is much larger than the folks that typically show up at DAC to visit the exhibit floor.  The question became, what value can DAC provide to the User Community? 

More questions and discussions.  Clearly, users would not be willing to spend the time writing length DAC papers, and the user contributions would not be looked upon with enthusiasm considering the main focus of DAC on algorithmic contributions and methodologies.

So, the User Track was born:  by users, for users, and chosen by users.  We decided on a conference format.  The submissions would be shorter.  The quality had to be high to attract others.  The event would be more inclusive and viewed as a community event to share knowledge and experiences.  The event had to offer networking opportunities.  Submissions must be evaluated using experts in tool use.

It is now eight months later.  We put together a committee of more than 20 super EDA users.  We put the word out that we are looking for submissions –– just one page abstracts.  We received 117 submissions spanning both front and back end design topics.  We accepted about one third as presentations, one third as posters, and one third did not make the quality cut for various reasons. 

I’ve already reviewed some of the presentations and posters that will be made at DAC, and they look GREAT.  Presenters include users from Infineon Technologies, Cisco, TI, Xilinx, ST Microelectronics, Intel, Virtutech, ClueLogic, ST Microelectronics, Samsung, Qualcomm, Intel, Fujitsu, IBM, Sun, and others.

The User Track is this three-day event with 40 presentations running in parallel with regular technical sessions, and a poster session, held Wednesday 1:30-3 p.m., which provides 42 posters.  Did I mention there will be ice cream, too, at the poster session?

Where else can you get such an experience –– the sessions, of course, and not the ice cream?  See you there! 


Reader Comments



at 6/25/2009 1:18:16 PM, who has time? said:
So users do not have the time to write EDA papers?

So, who the heck has the time to write them?

I know that the engineers that actually develop EDA tools are also lacking the time to write such things.

This may explain the general uselessness of papers at the major conferences...



at 6/25/2009 11:31:22 PM, Sean Murphy said:
DAC started as a community of practice amongst in-house EDA developers at major corporations. In 1982 enough of a vendor community existed that an exhibition floor was added. The challenge is that the papers and presentations have taken on too much of an academic focus. The User Track is a good first step in re-balancing things. I have high expectations for the Synopsys Conversation Central experiment and hope to see some interesting Birds of a Feather sessions as well. One format that might also be worth trying for next year's User Track is lightning talks, which are limited to 3-6 minutes with 3-6 slides allowed. It enables you to get more presentations done in an hour, lowers the barrier to participation, and can often spark lively discussions.



at 6/26/2009 9:04:21 AM, SteveM said:
An excellent move by Soha and the DAC program committee. The science, art and methodology of usage is more relevant and important than yet another placement partitioning algorithm. As an EDA developer I was inspired more by designers ideas and requests and always found the design presentations of great use to focus my views on requirements and application. It is great that DAC focusses more on the "Design" aspect. I sure hope that they are free to talk about their usage and tool experiences without constraints due to licensing terms.



at 7/4/2009 11:43:52 PM, flash said:
Perfect!

Post a comment



Display Name

Change Image
Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above.
Note the letters are NOT case sensitive.


ADVERTISEMENT

©1997-2010 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other Reed Business sites