Subscribe to EDN

Pandora: Absolutely Amazing, Begorrah!

March 26, 2009

Three Mondays back, I told you that I’d decided to cancel my Sirius Satellite Radio subscription, because I was no longer using the ’satellite’ part of the service and because I was unwilling to continue paying more than $100 per year for low-bitrate, Internet-sourced streaming audio. Now that I’ve sufficiently recovered from the HTML pummeling I got from Sirius shareholders, and now that my office is back together, I went searching this morning for a new source of work-hours (and for that matter, after-hours) background tunes.

Some friends had previously told me about their positive experiences with Pandora, but I confess that although I’m normally pretty leading-edge when it come to adopting new tech trends, I hadn’t yet gotten around to trying out the service. You begin by entering a musician or group that you like; Pandora builds a custom ‘channel’ based on tracks both by that artist and others of a similar genre. You can add musicians and groups to the channel profile to fine-tune the results; you can also give thumbs-up and –down ratings to individual tracks Pandora serves up in order to further customize the subsequent experience.

Within 10 minutes, I’d set up eight different channels based on the diversity of music genres I enjoy. I listened to them throughout the day, and I’m frankly blown away at how well the service tailors its content to my tastes. Pandora is the commercialization of the Music Genome Project, whose algorithm employs more than 400 different attributes (here’s another cut at them) to categorize and identify comparable pieces of music.

Unfortunately, Pandora’s continued fiscal viability (therefore longevity) is unclear, due to a long-running dispute with the record labels over royalty payment amounts. Given the music industry’s financial malaise, and given the declining influence of traditional radio as a promotional vehicle for new artists, I’m not surprised that the labels are striving to end radio’s longstanding performance royalty ‘free ride’. Conversely, I can’t comprehend why content rights owners are striving to put services like Pandora out of business.

At least half of the artists and songs I listened to today were new to me. Pandora makes it easy, albeit not obtrusively so, for listeners to one-click buy tracks they’re listening to (along with the albums containing them) online from merchants like Amazon. And if you try to skip through too many tracks in any given hour-long time period, Pandora informs you that its agreements with the labels put limitations on such behaviour, encouraging you to change channels if necessary in order to reset the ’skip counter’.

In striving to remain financially afloat, Pandora’s site contains a fair number of ads. But since I’m normally listening to it instead of looking at it, I don’t find them too obtrusive. And I haven’t yet come across any of the brief audio commercial interruptions that some users have reported. In addition to the web browser-based application, the company offers standalone apps for BlackBerry and Windows Mobile phones, the iPhone and iPod touch, and OS X and Windows. Here’s my list of stations, if you’d like to try them out for yourself.:

Posted by Brian Dipert on March 26, 2009 | Comments (3)

April 8, 2009
In response to: Pandora: Absolutely Amazing, Begorrah!
kghosh22 commented:

Pandora, Slacker .... are available only in the US.


March 30, 2009
In response to: Pandora: Absolutely Amazing, Begorrah!
rmahlab commented:

Enjoy your Pandora and Slacker, as well as other MUSIC freeloading services while they last, they will soon be out of business after this month''s pending court rejection of their appeal to steal music. By the way, how many singles or albums did you actually buy. I''ll bet the answer is very few if any. The record industry has no alternative but to charge more and that leaves these players out in the cold. SIRI may be getting a call from you soon.


March 27, 2009
In response to: Pandora: Absolutely Amazing, Begorrah!
Tom B. commented:

If you like Pandora, give Slacker a try. It''s more of a hybrid of Pandora & Sirius. They have some really good pre-programmed stations, but you also have the option to create your own stations. Also, their iPhone app is very superior and much more stable than Pandora''s. After only a few days of listening to Slacker, I ended up buying the year sub ($40 something) so that I could get unlimited skips and listen commercial free. But the free version is eminently listenable as I''d only hear a 30-second commercial every 5 or 6 songs. I was a big Pandora fan back in the day, but they repeat too many songs. Slacker is definitely the way to go. I just hope they stick around!

POST A COMMENT
Display Name
captcha

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above. Note the letters are case sensitive:

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
About EDN   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   Subscription   |   RSS
© 2012 UBM Electronics. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other UBM Canon sites

UBM Canon | Design News | Test & Measurement World | Packaging Digest | EDN | Qmed | Pharmalive | Appliance Magazine | Plastics Today | Powder Bulk Solids | Canon Trade Shows