Subscribe to EDN

Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum

August 20, 2007

After more than a year’s worth of releasing titles in both Blu-ray and HD DVD, Paramount and distribution partner DreamWorks Animation have both decided to exclusively focus on HD DVD going forward (PDF). Quoting from the press release:

The exclusive HD DVD commitment will include all movies distributed by Paramount Pictures, DreamWorks Pictures, Paramount Vantage, Nickelodeon Movies and MTV Films, as well as movies from DreamWorks Animation, which are distributed exclusively by Paramount Home Entertainment.

The first HD DVD-exclusive movie will be Blades of Glory, which should make my wife (a fan of both Will Ferrell and Jon Heder) quite happy.

Who was it who just said a few days ago that the format war was nowhere near over? Oh yes….now I remember….

Followup: I’d like to also direct your attention to this excellent writeup at BetaNews which echoes a point I’ve made many times in the past, most recently above when I compared the combined sales of Blu-ray and HD DVD against VHS. At this point in the game, Blu-ray and HD DVD’s primary competition isn’t each other, it’s red laser DVD (along with, for that matter, downloadable movies). And oh, by the way, Blu-ray and HD DVD’s combined sales are also only about 1% of red laser DVD at the moment. This has been a perspective service announcement….

Followup II: Ars Technica interviews Paramount’s CTO, who echoes a number of points I recently made.

Posted by Brian Dipert on August 20, 2007 | Comments (8)

August 29, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
NC-Guy commented:

Hmmm, let me see. Sony Blue-Ray player over $500 and Toshiba HD player $299. Who will win the format wars? Anyone remember Beta vs VHS? Beta was better but,...


August 22, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
Brian Dipert commented:

Dear One Format Only, you don't think the Blu-ray folks paid off Disney? Or paid Target for that recently-announced endcap exclusive in brick-and-mortar stores? C'mon....this is how business is done, on BOTH sides of this format war.


August 22, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
One Format Only commented:

HD DVD is getting desperate, they've paid Paramount...


August 22, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
A Reader commented:

Brian is bias over HD DVD. It's obvious.


August 21, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
One Format Only commented:

Remember SACD and DVD Audio? Can you see it everywhere these days? No. The reason is because of the "format war". If the war between Blu-ray and HD DVD will be prolonged, consumer adoption will also be prolonged.


August 21, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
One Format Only commented:

This format war should and must be over by next year... what's more likely: Sony, Fox, and Disney supporting HD DVD? or Paramount and Universal supporting Blu-ray? I think the latter is more realistic. By the way, next year BD-J is already equal with HDi in terms of interactivity (actually October 31 this year to be precise).


August 21, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
1 commented:

Paramount's decision is just plain stupid. Are they interested in promoting high-definition entertainment? Or just paid by some... the more even the support for HD DVD and Blu-ray is, the longer the adoption of high-def will be. The momentum is already on Blu-ray, I think it's really foolish for them to go back to an inferior format. Are they concerned with us, the consumers???


August 20, 2007
In response to: Blu-ray Vs. HD DVD: The Perpetually Oscillating Pendulum
Janosh commented:

I do not own a player or disk of either format (for obvious reasons), but I totally root for blu-ray for one simple reason: it's better (i.e. more storage capacity) and eventually, the price will be the same as that of HD DVD. Just look at current DVDs. A DVD costs about 50 cents to manufacture, and sells between $9 and $25. The format wars had better resolve soon, or else some third standard, an open-source / royaltees free one maybe, will replace them both.

POST A COMMENT
Display Name
captcha

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above. Note the letters are case sensitive:

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
About EDN   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   Subscription   |   RSS
© 2012 UBM Electronics. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other UBM Canon sites

UBM Canon | Design News | Test & Measurement World | Packaging Digest | EDN | Qmed | Pharmalive | Appliance Magazine | Plastics Today | Powder Bulk Solids | Canon Trade Shows