Satellite-Served Internet: So Slow
Greetings from an RV park in the outskirts of Torrey, Utah. The only cellular provider out here in the beautiful middle of nowhere is Qwest, whose service is incompatible with all four cellular data plans I've got access to (Cingular, Sprint, T-Mobile and Verizon). So, I spent an extra $2.95 for access to the RVP park's 802.11b network, which I initially presumed was being fed by cable or DSL but, after I spied the dish on the roof, I realized was hosted by DirecWay.
I've heard horror stories about satellite 'net service, and I've even written about it from an airplane-based client perspective, but this is the first time I've personally test-driven it. And I must say, it's about as underwhelming as I'd been told it was. In one sense, actually, it's quite fast; as I type this, I'm downloading Pearl Jam's Rearviewmirror album from Yahoo Music Unlimited at a 1 Mbps clip. However, if I ping www.google.com, I best-case get responses in 3/4 of a second….usually, the replies from Google's server take 1.5 seconds or longer to reach me. That means, for example, that EVERY request my web browser makes for a piece of content takes 1.5 seconds to begin loading.
How many frames' worth of text does the average web page contain? How many images? Etc? See why DirecWay seems slow, even though from a downstream bandwidth standpoint it's actually fairly fast? And there's one final gripe; if I attempt to 'do too many things at once', i.e. use my web browser while Yahoo Music Engine is simultaneously downloading music tracks, or Outlook is downloading email or RSS feeds (in conjunction with NewsGator's plugin), the error message below will invariably pop up in my browser:
Suspected Recent Satellite Link Outage (Error 506)
The satellite link was operating properly up until the most recent web page request, but the last request could not be successfully sent across the satellite link to the DIRECWAY Network Operations Center. Possible causes for this include recent changes in weather conditions or equipment problems in the DIRECWAY Network Operations Center. Retrying the web page may correct the problem.
Granted, I don't know how much the RV park's DirecWay connection is being used right now; the park is pretty full. So maybe this isn't a fair test (although, given the download bandwidth I'm seeing from Yahoo Music Unlimited, I 'spect I've got the DirectWay connection all to myself right now). For those of you who've used DirecWay, does my experience mimic yours?
By the way, the Kyocera KR1 router worked great last night outside Bryce Canyon National Park, where both Sprint and Verizon had 1xRTT service. My wife and I were simultaneously online via our respective laptops, and as long as we weren't accessing the Internet at the same time, we each experienced full 1xRTT bandwidth.
Followup: Ironically, the May issue of IEEE Spectrum contains an article covering an 14-city municipally owned, fiber optic-based 100 Mbps broadband network now being deployed in the Wasatch Valley (Interstate 15 corridor) of Utah, just to the north and west of where I was sipping from a slow satellite straw….
liminommumb commented:
hughesnet rebelion commented:
Costa Rica Internet Services commented:
dan in s carolina commented:
FuminginNC commented:
richard wilbur commented:
Tranzorb commented:
Respones to others. commented:
Colorado commented:
W.D. Fair commented:
Frank commented:
Frank commented:
palmerpond5600 commented:
LuisB commented:
Brian Dipert commented:
Brian Dipert commented:















