Subscribe to EDN

Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?

June 22, 2009

There has been much uproar about the Wall Street Journal report released over the weekend claiming that 54-year-old Apple cofounder Steve Jobs had a liver transplant two months ago in Tennessee. Apple has not issued an official statement, nor is it expected to do so immediately as Jobs was out on medical leave at the time and the company has covered its legal bases by publicly stated that back in January when it vaguely announced its leader was suffering from a "hormone imbalance." Perhaps a statement will come when Jobs returns to his desk; he is slated to do so at the end of the month.

Holders of Apple stock, AAPL, have long criticized the company for not being more upfront about Job’s health issues, issues that date back to the 1990s when he was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. AAPL has been negatively impacted by Jobs health rumors and the occasional official statement from Apple.

After the stock climbed on Friday as consumers lined up to buy the latest iPhone, it took a dive today, decreasing by $2.11 to close at $137.37. Part of the decline was forced by today’s overall weak market and part, most likely, was caused by Wall Street fear that Jobs’ health is once again waning.

Why has Apple not shifted its spotlight or at least widened it to more commonly include others? The company is dripping with talent — more like oozing, actually — yet the public face solely remains an obviously ill Jobs. Why not show off your other shining stars, allowing stockholders and consumers to more clearly see an executive transition plan, when the company can succeed without Jobs everyday presence? Note that Apple three days intosold more than a million iPhone 3G S devices, handsets priced at $99, $199, and $299 — not pocket change given the current recession’s squeeze on consumer spending.

Perhaps if I owned AAPL* my view would be different. Perhaps I’d be shouting from rooftops that every detail of Jobs’ health is a matter of public disclosure, as it evidently impacts AAPL stock price. Perhaps even if I was a CEO at one of the many chip makers that do business with Apple and that have seen how quickly business can change when Apple slips or takes its business away (recall PortalPlayer’s 2006 loss of its Apple contract and later acquisition by Nvidia), I’d be clamoring for every bit of info on liver transplants I could get my hands on. (By the way, the American Liver Foundation reports that in 2005 there were about 6,500 liver transplants performed in the United States and estimates the five-year survival rate for a liver transplant is around 75%.)

We all know Apple slumped once before when Jobs stepped away. But that was before the company broke through to mainstream consumers with the iPod. Tim Cook, Apple’s COO and the man left in charge while Jobs has been out these last six months, has done a nice job maintaining the company in its CEO’s absence. I, like my colleague Brian Dipert, wish Jobs every blessing there is for a speedy return to good health and can’t begin to express the value this man has brought to the electronics industry within our blog tool’s posting limits. Still, I have to wonder if it is time for him to hand the reins over to someone else at Apple, or at least to begin to express such a transition plan.

Should Jobs step out of the spotlight? Could Cook, with his engineering degree and business background, continue the company’s growth and innovative devices? Would such a move be good for Apple and its product lines? Voice your opinions below.

Update, June 24, 5pm: Methodist University Hospital Transplant Institute in Memphis confirmed that it had preformed a liver transplant on Steve Jobs. The institute said Jobs received the transplant because he was the "sickest patient on the waiting list at the time a donor organ became available." On June 23, the institute reported Jobs is recovering well and has an excellent prognosis. As of this update, Apple has not issued an official statement.

*Editor’s note: It is considered unethical for journalists to own stock in the companies they report on. For this reason, the author owns no AAPL stock or stock in companies related to or that do business with Apple.

Posted by Suzanne Deffree on June 22, 2009 | Comments (7)

August 30, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
twiter commented:

Good luck. I monitor your accounts regularly


June 27, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
Scunnerous commented:

I think what we're witnessing right now is the approximate half-way point in an "organic" handover of the reins. In the next year or so, there'll be a day when some wag asks about the heir to the throne and Apple's answer will be that it's all already happened and that "Steve's been changing light bulbs and looking after the Apple gardens for the past 6 months. Tim et.al. have been effectively running the show all that time and nobody noticed any degradation of management or corporate innovation and direction." IOW there'll be no day of catastrophe or Apple Armageddon. At least that seems to me to be a clever strategy for handling the ultimate inevitable. Whatever time Steve has left on this earth, and I hope it's not brief, in his shoes I'd probably want to spend it on family pursuits. Good luck to them all.


June 24, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
Tom tom commented:

Good to see you blogging again, Susanne. I think it is time for Jobs to 'step out of the spotlight'. Cook is a good leader. Apple needs a healthy guy steering the ship and Jobs needs to focus on his health.


June 24, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
David R commented:

Apple has done well over the years. Every good company has it's ups and downs- but it's the great companies that recover quickly and promote growth - throughout the industry. Apple is such a company! I wish Mr. Jobs a speedy recovery and if he ever decides to pass on the reins to Mr. Cook, I am sure the company will continue to be successful. Apple's innovation and industrial command presence continues to lead us into the future, it is not because the presences of one person but because as a whole, the company is built on a great fondation.


June 23, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
Baskaran commented:

There is a thin line between decency and your right as a share holder to know what is happening to SJ. If you choose to worry about the value dropping due to his health - better mitigate by a strategy than to curse and swear this man or just sell the shares and wish this man good luck.


June 23, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
Joe P commented:

This column is more palatable than the other I read on EDN. Steve has a tremendous gift that he shared with the world. But it is time he stepped down. Health is true wealth and he needs to put that first.


June 23, 2009
In response to: Jobs liver transplant: Is it time for Apple to officially name a new leader?
desert rat commented:

I said it yesterday in Brian's blog, and I will say it here again: you are walking flatfooted into the legal conflict of personal privacy rights vs stockholder rights. Jobs probably did an "adequate disclosure" that he had health problems, and was taking a medical leave. Only a lawsuit by stockholders (showing damages) can resolve the issue of personal privacy vs stockholder rights. Should APPL have a person in the on-deck circle to replace Jobs? Sure. Every public company should have such a plan of succession. And, I suspect the APPL BOD has such a plan. But I don't believe they have any fiduciary duty to disclose it at this point.

POST A COMMENT
Display Name
captcha

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above. Note the letters are case sensitive:

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
About EDN   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   Subscription   |   RSS
© 2011 UBM Electronics. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other UBM Canon sites

UBM Canon | Design News | Test & Measurement World | Packaging Digest | EDN | Qmed | Pharmalive | Appliance Magazine | Plastics Today | Powder Bulk Solids | Canon Trade Shows