Subscribe to EDN

The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue

October 25, 2006

The Assocated Press reported today that the gentleman that originally cracked DVD security has also cracked the iTunes DRM and plans to market the technology, whereas he has posted his previous work for free. You can read the story “Hacker claims to have cracked iPod restrictions” on the cnn.com web site.

The primary reaction today seems to be that the crack doesn’t matter. For instance in “iPod cracked, but does it matter?” the folks at Slashdot claim that anyone can convert iTunes sonds to the MP3 format. Generally they are correct, but the methods they suggest do result in a reduction in audio quality. The reduction comes courtesy of the initial iTunes compression, followed by analog capture, a second digitization stage, and yet another round of compression. A widely-distributed iTunes crack might make music available in a quality equal to the experience a CD owner can achieve when ripping a CD.

From my perspective, I’ll continue to boycott iTunes until the codec and DRM is opened to third parties. I believe that untold numbers of iTunes customers don’t realize that the money they are spending on iTunes could have no more long term value than the money spent on 8-track music in the 70’s. Apple seems set in the path that the music will only play on Apple devices. But frankly I don’t think carrying an iPod in a car is the right solution. The codec and DRM should be licensed to the car stereo vendor.

Now as for a crack, I’m not sure that’s what we should hope for either, although perhaps it could spur Apple to action. I’d prefer that Apple wakeup and open their technology. Their refusal to do so cost them a chance to be dominant in the PC business, and I think it will still haunt them in music as well.

Posted by Maury Wright on October 25, 2006 | Comments (17)

December 10, 2007
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
tee hee commented:

i know the crack! well ive found it nayway. and now my ipod is complete


December 10, 2007
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
tee hee commented:

i know the crack! well ive found it nayway. and now my ipod is complete


December 10, 2007
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
tee hee commented:

i know the crack! well ive found it nayway. and now my ipod is complete


September 23, 2007
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
globalleader commented:

Uh, DRM is there because of the record companies, and Apple can't give out it's technology to others because of their agreement with the record companies. That would be like inventing a safe and giving out the master code to a bunch of people. This is all very obvious to me, but I'll let you figure it out for yourselves.


September 23, 2007
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
globalleader commented:

Uh, DRM is there because of the record companies, and Apple can't give out it's technology to others because of their agreement with the record companies. That would be like inventing a safe and giving out the master code to a bunch of people. This is all very obvious to me, but I'll let you figure it out for yourselves.


September 23, 2007
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
globalleader commented:

Uh, DRM is there because of the record companies, and Apple can't give out it's technology to others because of their agreement with the record companies. That would be like inventing a safe and giving out the master code to a bunch of people. This is all very obvious to me, but I'll let you figure it out for yourselves.


October 27, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Monkeyshine commented:

Oh i mean to say, the car should have its own entertainment console with wifi and/or a cat5 connection and dvd/cd reader. This way you can watch movies, play/import cd's and dvds of music, and synch to your music and video collection via remote. I dont see why apple should get a second slice of the same pie. they got paid for selling it to me now let me play it where I want when I want like I did with my CDs and tapes and 8 tracks. I direct these posts to the author of the article and for others to consider/.


October 27, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Monkeyshine commented:

Oh i mean to say, the car should have its own entertainment console with wifi and/or a cat5 connection and dvd/cd reader. This way you can watch movies, play/import cd's and dvds of music, and synch to your music and video collection via remote. I dont see why apple should get a second slice of the same pie. they got paid for selling it to me now let me play it where I want when I want like I did with my CDs and tapes and 8 tracks. I direct these posts to the author of the article and for others to consider/.


October 27, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Monkeyshine commented:

You are almost right. You can get cars with DVD players for the kids in the backseat. But I don't know why iTunes should get to profit on top of song sales by licensing a codec. They would have changed music too much. In the past you could buy music anywhere and play it anywhere. Now you say if I buy music from itunes I can only play it if aaple gets a royalty? crap. Why don't cars come with 500 gig drives and a dvd and let me play any format. I dont and never will use apples codecs. I don't buy from itunes. i keep everything in mp3 and play it on my ipod and anywhere else I want via itunes, musicmatch, windows mediaplayer and more.


October 27, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Monkeyshine commented:

You are almost right. You can get cars with DVD players for the kids in the backseat. But I don't know why iTunes should get to profit on top of song sales by licensing a codec. They would have changed music too much. In the past you could buy music anywhere and play it anywhere. Now you say if I buy music from itunes I can only play it if aaple gets a royalty? crap. Why don't cars come with 500 gig drives and a dvd and let me play any format. I dont and never will use apples codecs. I don't buy from itunes. i keep everything in mp3 and play it on my ipod and anywhere else I want via itunes, musicmatch, windows mediaplayer and more.


October 26, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
jeff_l commented:

This supposed "crack" to Apple's DRM is a fairly mot point since iTunes allows m4p tracks to be burned to CD at without ditgital-to-analog conversion and while simultaneously stripping any DRM. Those tracks can then be reimported in mp3 format and used in any way the user sees fit. So, the DRM amounts to an annoyance and small cost.


October 26, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
jeff_l commented:

This supposed "crack" to Apple's DRM is a fairly mot point since iTunes allows m4p tracks to be burned to CD at without ditgital-to-analog conversion and while simultaneously stripping any DRM. Those tracks can then be reimported in mp3 format and used in any way the user sees fit. So, the DRM amounts to an annoyance and small cost.


October 26, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
jeff_l commented:

This supposed "crack" to Apple's DRM is a fairly mot point since iTunes allows m4p tracks to be burned to CD at without ditgital-to-analog conversion and while simultaneously stripping any DRM. Those tracks can then be reimported in mp3 format and used in any way the user sees fit. So, the DRM amounts to an annoyance and small cost.


October 26, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Patrick commented:

I tend to think that having the iPod in the car *is* the solution : I'm certainly not interested in burning CDs or DVDs regularly to make my playlists for my car stereo ! I far more prefer to have my iPod (or my iRiver, since I have both) in the car, and synchronize it with my computer. But I certainly agree with your views concerning Apple's strategy : I cannot foresee any long term benefit from Apple's closed technology strategy. The great lesson of history is that men learn nothing from history, or so it seems.


October 26, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Patrick commented:

I tend to think that having the iPod in the car *is* the solution : I'm certainly not interested in burning CDs or DVDs regularly to make my playlists for my car stereo ! I far more prefer to have my iPod (or my iRiver, since I have both) in the car, and synchronize it with my computer. But I certainly agree with your views concerning Apple's strategy : I cannot foresee any long term benefit from Apple's closed technology strategy. The great lesson of history is that men learn nothing from history, or so it seems.


October 25, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Anonymous commented:

The true reason Apple is closed about it's DRM is the fact that it would be embarrsing for them to open such "DRM" implementation, as it would demonstrate to everybody how easy it is to be cracked, that it would be hardly even named "DRM" and the only reason it's there is due to DMCA...


October 25, 2006
In response to: The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
Anonymous commented:

The true reason Apple is closed about it's DRM is the fact that it would be embarrsing for them to open such "DRM" implementation, as it would demonstrate to everybody how easy it is to be cracked, that it would be hardly even named "DRM" and the only reason it's there is due to DMCA...

POST A COMMENT
Display Name
captcha

Before submitting this form, please type the characters displayed above. Note the letters are case sensitive:

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
About EDN   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   Subscription   |   RSS
© 2012 UBM Electronics. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Please visit these other UBM Canon sites

UBM Canon | Design News | Test & Measurement World | Packaging Digest | EDN | Qmed | Pharmalive | Appliance Magazine | Plastics Today | Powder Bulk Solids | Canon Trade Shows