The iTunes DRM crack could matter: legal battle sure to ensue
The Assocated Press reported today that the gentleman that originally cracked DVD security has also cracked the iTunes DRM and plans to market the technology, whereas he has posted his previous work for free. You can read the story “Hacker claims to have cracked iPod restrictions” on the cnn.com web site.
The primary reaction today seems to be that the crack doesn’t matter. For instance in “iPod cracked, but does it matter?” the folks at Slashdot claim that anyone can convert iTunes sonds to the MP3 format. Generally they are correct, but the methods they suggest do result in a reduction in audio quality. The reduction comes courtesy of the initial iTunes compression, followed by analog capture, a second digitization stage, and yet another round of compression. A widely-distributed iTunes crack might make music available in a quality equal to the experience a CD owner can achieve when ripping a CD.
From my perspective, I’ll continue to boycott iTunes until the codec and DRM is opened to third parties. I believe that untold numbers of iTunes customers don’t realize that the money they are spending on iTunes could have no more long term value than the money spent on 8-track music in the 70’s. Apple seems set in the path that the music will only play on Apple devices. But frankly I don’t think carrying an iPod in a car is the right solution. The codec and DRM should be licensed to the car stereo vendor.
Now as for a crack, I’m not sure that’s what we should hope for either, although perhaps it could spur Apple to action. I’d prefer that Apple wakeup and open their technology. Their refusal to do so cost them a chance to be dominant in the PC business, and I think it will still haunt them in music as well.
tee hee commented:
tee hee commented:
tee hee commented:
globalleader commented:
globalleader commented:
globalleader commented:
Monkeyshine commented:
Monkeyshine commented:
Monkeyshine commented:
Monkeyshine commented:
jeff_l commented:
jeff_l commented:
jeff_l commented:
Patrick commented:
Patrick commented:
Anonymous commented:
Anonymous commented:















